Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... Orphan Trains: The Story of Charles Loring Brace and the Children He Saved and Failed (edition 2001)by Stephen O'Connor (Author)Sending orphans on trains and leaving them with total strangers with little vetting or followup sounds horrible judging by modern standards. Charles Loring Brace was considered a visionary by many people as the founder of the CAS (Children's Aid Society). Around 250,000 children were processed between 1854 and 1929. They traveled from New York City to many destinations. I decided to read a book about these trains after going to a presentation, at the library, about orphan trains that delivered their "cargo" to Michigan. Unfortunately, since the record keeping and followup was shoddy at best, it is impossible to determine the overall success or failure of this effort. There are many accounts of incredible success stories and of children who suffered terrible abuse. The rampant problems of children abandoned on the streets of New York City including those in the desperately poor Five Points neighborhood compelled the CAS to act. This book gives us a good understanding of the morals and ethics of the times, the conditions the children endured, several examples of these riders, the life of Charles Loring Brace and the history of the orphan trains. Sending orphans on trains and leaving them with total strangers with little vetting or followup sounds horrible judging by modern standards. Charles Loring Brace was considered a visionary by many people as the founder of the CAS (Children's Aid Society). Around 250,000 children were processed between 1854 and 1929. They traveled from New York City to many destinations. I decided to read a book about these trains after going to a presentation, at the library, about orphan trains that delivered their "cargo" to Michigan. Unfortunately, since the record keeping and followup was shoddy at best, it is impossible to determine the overall success or failure of this effort. There are many accounts of incredible success stories and of children who suffered terrible abuse. The rampant problems of children abandoned on the streets of New York City including those in the desperately poor Five Points neighborhood compelled the CAS to act. This book gives us a good understanding of the morals and ethics of the times, the conditions the children endured, several examples of these riders, the life of Charles Loring Brace and the history of the orphan trains. Several months ago, the MO Readers read a short book about the orphan trains in Missouri, and we thought we'd like to know more, so we read this one. Although it barely touched on Missouri, some of the stories he told were fascinating. However, I couldn't help feeling like the author had an agenda. He played up the bad stories and played down the good ones, and I felt like he was using a modern scale to weigh things that happened in the past. I am CERTAINLY not in favor of making children work to earn their keep, or beating them for little reason, but a lot of the situations he blamed on Brace were really just how things were in those days. In general, I believe that working on a farm, even working hard, had to beat the heck out of starving to death. And even though some of the adopting parents were cruel, they weren't much worse than some of the real parents the children were escaping. He attempted to be even-handed, but I felt like he was forcing himself to do it, and it didn't resonate with me. |
Current DiscussionsNonePopular covers
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)362.73Social sciences Social problems and services; associations Social problems of & services to groups of people Child welfare AdoptionLC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |