Messrs. Robert Rantoul, Silas Rawson, David Rice, Luther Richards, Daniel Richardson, David S. Ross, John Sherril, Gideon Stiles, Alfred L. Strong, Messrs. Alanson Swain, Arnold Taft, Those who voted in the negative are :— Messrs. Benjamin P. Adams, P. Emory Aldrich, James B. Allen, John B. Alley, Robert Andrews, Eliakim A. Bates, Erasmus D. Beach, William Bennett, Jr., Edward B. Bigelow, Willard Thayer, 2d, David P. Turner, Freeland Wallis, Amasa Walker, Otis Wood, Ezekiel Wright. Messrs. Chester W. Chapin, Daniel E. Chapin, Josiah Childs, Alpheus B. Clarke, Jacob Coggin, Nathaniel Cogswell, Lansing J. Cole, Charles E. Cook, Henry F. Cooledge, Simeon Crittenden, George W. Crockett, Leander Crosby, Seth Crowell, Francis B. Crowninshield, Joseph Cummings, John Davis, Solomon Davis, Henry L. Dawes, James C. Doane, Francis Brinley, George N. Briggs, Adolphus F. Brown, Frederick Brownell, Rufus Bullock, Cephas C. Bumpus, Timothy W. Carter, Moses Dorman, Peter Easland, Lilley Eaton, William T. Eustis, Samuel Henry, Henry Hersey, Aaron Hobart, George Hood, Thomas Hopkinson, Samuel Houghton, William J. Hubbard, William Hunt, Asahel Huntington, Samuel Jackson, William James, John Jenkins, Samuel H. Jenks, Henry W. Kinsman, Hiram Knight, Joseph Knight, George H. Kuhn, Alden Leland, Frederic W. Lincoln, Jr., Tristram Littlefield, Isaac Livermore, Samuel K. Lothrop, Samuel P. Loud, Theophilus R. Marvin, Seth Miller, Jr., Henry K. Oliver, Nathan Orcutt, Charles Osgood, James W. Paige, Eben H. Stacy, Caleb Stetson, Joseph L. Stevens, Jr., J. Thomas Stevenson, Thomas Talbot, Edmund P. Tileston, Horatio W. Tilton, Charles R. Train, David Turner, John S. Tyler, Charles W. Upham, Bradford L. Wales, Samuel Walker, Marshal Warner, Cyrus Weeks, Thomas Wetmore, William F. Wheeler, Benjamin White, Joel Wilder, John H. Wilkins, Messrs. Henry Williams, J. B. Williams, Messrs. Charles C. Wood, Nathaniel Wood. Jonathan B. Winn, On motion of Mr. CROWNINSHIELD, of Boston, the yeas and nays were ordered upon the question of adopting the amendment offered by Mr. Dana. And the roll being called, one hundred and sixty-nine members voted in the affirmative, and one hundred and eighty-eight in the ative. So it was rejected. Those who voted in the affirmative are: Messrs. Benjamin P. Adams, P. Emory Aldrich, Robert Andrews, Russel Bartlett, Sidney Bartlett, Erasmus D. Beach, James M. Beebe, Luther V. Bell, William Bennett, Jr., Jacob Bigelow, Gad O. Bliss, William C. Bliss, Milton P. Braman, Hiram N. Breed, Osmyn Brewster, Francis Brinley, George N. Briggs, Rufus Bullock, Cephas C. Bumpus, Timothy W. Carter, Lansing J. Cole, Ithamar Conkey, Messrs. Seth Crowell, neg Francis B. Crowninshield, Joseph Cummings, Richard H. Dana, Jr., John Davis, Solomon Davis, Henry L. Dawes, A. G. Farwell, Samuel P. Fowler, Charles H. French, Richard Frothingham, Jr., Wanton C. Gilbert, Robert Gould, Dalton Goulding, Jason Goulding, John C. Gray, Whiting Griswold, A. B. Hammond, George Hayward, Messrs. Levi Heywood, George S. Hillard, William Hinsdale, Aaron Hobart, Nathaniel Holder, Foster Hooper, Frederic W. Lincoln, Jr., Otis P. Lord, Samuel K. Lothrop, Samuel P. Loud, Nathan Orcutt, Charles Osgood, James W. Paige, John G. Park, Messrs. Joel Parker, George Peabody, Daniel A. Perkins, Jonathan C. Perkins, William C. Plunkett, Jonathan Preston, George R. Sampson, John W. Thomas, Charles R. Train, David Turner, Charles W. Upham, Joel Wilder, Henry Williams, Adolphus G. Parker, Those who voted in the negative are: Messrs. Josiah G. Abbott, Shubael P. Adams, Joel C. Allen, Messrs. Parsons Allen, John B. Alley, Messrs. Peter Easland, Messrs. D. W. Alvord, George S. Ball, Marcus Barrett, Eliakim A. Bates, Moses Bates, Jr., William J. A. Bradford, Asa Bronson, Joseph Brownell, Daniel E. Chapin, Henry Chapin, J. McKean Churchill, Henry Clark, Ransom Clark, Stillman Clarke, William Cleverly, Philip Eames, Elisha Edwards, Samuel Edwards, Joseph M. Ely, Ezekiel W. Fitch, Elbridge Gates, Washington Gilbert, Seth Hapgood, Elnathan P. Hathaway, Isaac Hayden, Charles C. Hazewell, Ezra Heath, 2d, William H. Hewes, Abraham H. Howland, Henry K. Hoyt, Albert Knox, Gardner P. Ladd, Alden Leland, |