Dred Scott and the Problem of Constitutional Evil

Cover
Cambridge University Press, 03.07.2006
Dred Scott and the Problem of Constitutional Evil , first published in 2006, concerns what is entailed by pledging allegiance to a constitutional text and tradition saturated with concessions to evil. The Constitution of the United States was originally understood as an effort to mediate controversies between persons who disputed fundamental values, and did not offer a vision of the good society. In order to form a 'more perfect union' with slaveholders, late-eighteenth-century citizens fashioned a constitution that plainly compelled some injustices and was silent or ambiguous on other questions of fundamental right. This constitutional relationship could survive only as long as a bisectional consensus was required to resolve all constitutional questions not settled in 1787. Dred Scott challenges persons committed to human freedom to determine whether antislavery northerners should have provided more accommodations for slavery than were constitutionally strictly necessary or risked the enormous destruction of life and property that preceded Lincoln's new birth of freedom.
 

Was andere dazu sagen - Rezension schreiben

LibraryThing Review

Nutzerbericht  - nbmars - LibraryThing

Mark Graber begins his book with the observation that legal scholars almost universally proclaim that the Dred Scott decision was wrong. To the contrary, Graber argues that "the result in Dred Scott v ... Vollständige Rezension lesen

Ausgewählte Seiten

Inhalt

Introduction
1
The Problem of Constitutional Evil
8
Slavery as a Constitutional Evil
12
THE LESSONS OF DRED SCOTT
15
The Dred Scott Decision
18
Critiques of Dred Scott
20
The Institutional Critique
23
The Historical Critique
24
18201860
126
The Constitution and the Civil War
167
Law and Politics
168
COMPROMISING WITH EVIL
173
Mojoritarianism and Constitutional Evil
179
Problems with Democratic Majoritarianism
186
Contract Consent and Constitutional Evil
198
Lincoln on Constitutional Contracts and Constitutional Evil
200

The Aspirational Critique
26
Critiquing the Critiques
28
The Institutional Critique
30
The Historical Critique
46
The Aspirational Critique
76
Injustice and Constitutional Law
83
From Constitutional Law to Constitutional Politics
85
THE CONSTITUTIONAL POLITICS OF SLAVERY
91
The Slavery Comprises Revisited
93
The Original Constitutional Politics of Slavery
96
Accommodating Evil in 1787
106
Cracks in the Constitutional Consensus
109
Toward the Future
114
The Compromises and Constitutional Development
115
The Contractual Conception of Constitutional Evil
205
The Constitution as a Contract
207
Cracks in the Constitutional Contract
210
Frustration of Constitution
217
Constitutional Relationships and Constitutional Evil
219
The Constitution as a Relational Contract
220
The Constitutional Case for Abandoning the Constitution of 1787
226
Voting for John Bell
237
Lincoln versus Bell
241
The Constitution of Todays Lincoln Voters
243
The Constitution of Todays Bell Voters
247
Constitutional Justice or Constitutional Peace
252
Index
255
Urheberrecht

Andere Ausgaben - Alle anzeigen

Häufige Begriffe und Wortgruppen

Über den Autor (2006)

Mark A. Graber is a Professor of Government at the University of Maryland College Park and a Professor of Law at the University of Maryland School of Law. He previously taught law and political science at the University of Texas. He is the author of Transforming Free Speech (1991), Rethinking Abortion (1996), and numerous articles on American constitutional development, law and politics. His many awards include the Edward Corwin Prize (best dissertation), the Hughes Goessart Prize (best article in the Journal of the History of the Supreme Court), and the Congressional Quarterly Prize (best published article on public law). He is a member of the American Political Science Association and the American Association of Law Schools. During the 2005 academic year, he was head of the Law and Courts section of the American Political Science Association.

Bibliografische Informationen