National Reporter System.-State Series.

THE

PACIFIC REPORTER,

VOLUME 72,

CONTAINING ALL THE DECISIONS OF THE

SUPREME COURTS OF CALIFORNIA, KANSAS, OREGON, WASHINGTON,
COLORADO, MONTANA, ARIZONA, NEVADA, IDAHO, WYOMING,
UTAH, NEW MEXICO, OKLAHOMA, AND COURT
OF APPEALS OF COLORADO.

PERMANENT EDITION.

MAY 4-AUGUST 3, 1903.

WITH TABLE OF PACIFIC CASES IN WHICH REHEARINGS HAVE BEEN GRANTED OR Denied.

ST. PAUL:

WEST PUBLISHING CO.

1903.

RF
1357

COPYRIGHT, 1903,

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY.
(72 PAC.)

PACIFIC REPORTER, VOLUME 72.

JUDGES

COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD COVERED BY THIS VOLUME.

OF THE

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

RICHARD E. SLOAN.
GEORGE R. DAVIS.

WILLIAM H. BEATTY, CHIEF JUSTICE.

THOMAS B. MCFARLAND.
F. W. HENSHAW.
WALTER VAN DYKE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

Supreme Court Commissioners.

1 Term expired April 1, 1903.

2 Became President April 1, 1903.

WILLIAM H. GABBERT.

F. M. ANGELLOTTI.
LUCIEN SHAW.
W. G. LORIGAN.

GEORGE H. SMITH.

COLORADO-Supreme Court.

JOHN CAMPBELL, CHIEF Justice.

CHARLES I. THOMSON.a

WHEATON A. GRAY.
J. A. COOPER.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

Court of Appeals.

ADAIR WILSON, PRESIDENT.1
CHARLES I. THOM: ON, PRESIDENT."

ROBERT W. STEELE

JUDGES.

JULIUS C. GUNTER
JOHN M. MAXWELL.3

IDAHO-Supreme Court.

ISAAC N. SULLIVAN, CHIEF JUSTICE.

CHARLES O. STOCKSLAGER. JAMES F. AILSHIE

JUSTICES.

(iii)

Appointed April 6, 1903.